Wednesday, November 3, 2010

Yes, I highly believe that they should have restrained themselves and that countries or any empire should in fact adaopt a level of restraint on the amount of power one has. I say this becuase without this restraint in power the world and or the region that is being governed with be in terms "a mess". Choatic, and things wouldn't flow as how they should. Yes this is a sign of weakness though not all signs are certain and permanent. One can always regain control and rebound with much more strength then before. In the Peloponnesian War excerpt by Thucydides, the Athenians were without a doubt extremely more powerful than the Melians who were far under them in class status. However, rather than taking control and "stepping all over them" they opted to instead engage their power into negotiating with the nobles of Island. Though, when they know that they can easily just take over and conquer them so that there will be no need for any type of negotiation becuase the Melians are much weaker than them. What is being displayed by the Athenians are there loyal character, and restraint or power. Now, in my opinion this does not make the Athenians powerless or weaker than before. Being fair is apart of your responsibility with power.

4 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with you that even though the athenians restrained themselves from the melians it doesnt necessarily show that they are weak just because they didnt take over the melians by force.

    ReplyDelete
  3. i also agree with the above commenter and philip. just because a higher power does not decide to exemplify there force on another, does not mean that they are weak. power is not only shown through your forceful actions of hatred and conquery, but through your ability to retrain yourself and show personal control as a whole

    ReplyDelete
  4. Guys...LOOK at the reading. After the Athenians spoke to the Melians, they went to war with them. "After a hard fight, Athens won. The Athenians killed all the Melian men. They sold the women and children into slavery."

    Are you saying the Athenians showed restraint? Seems pretty brutal to me.

    More to the point, Philip you seem to say that restraint would help the Athenians. How much? Should they have just walked away from the Melains? Didn't they have a war to win?

    ReplyDelete