Societies should have some mutually agreed upon boundaries on conduct otherwise the society becomes a time bomb. There would be no functioning government laws or fair justice system because nobody would be able to agree on what should be outlawed or punished. There have to be if not rules guidelines and the either the majority or the people near the top of the chain of command would make those guidelines. That is an example of might makes right.
Some people have their own internal guidelines that they set for themselves, call it a moral compass, a conscience or voice of experience, there is a little voice inside everybody's head that says do or don't do that. You could say that it is keeping us from doing what we want by telling us what could happen, or in some cases what we are doing to the other person.
In the Pelopennisian Wars section I believe that the Athenians should have restrained themselves on the matter of the Melians, if nothing else than as a good faith gesture to show they mean no harm to the other islands. I can't help but think of those actions and the long term consequences. The act of standing down could work in the Athenians favor by giving them allies in the war against Sparta. The Melians could ally with the Spartans and rise up against the hold the Athenians who would lose lives and waste resources by trying to hold off an uprising that could have been avoided with a compromise. This isnt a naive gesture of fairness it is a calculated move that could work in the favor of all parties
i completely agree with this statement. I agree with this statement because I believe it is very important to come to a mutual set of boundaries of conduct. I believe it is important to have these boundaries because otherwise the majority of the population will be in constant disagreement and most likely not be an efficient country/town/city.I also believe it is important to set a certain code of moral conduct that everyone should be expected to follow.
ReplyDeleteI agree with what Claire and Olivia have stated that a country should try to develope some moral boundaries; howeve,;I think that nation states always act in their own best interest without regard to the victims. Developing a set of moral codes and boundaries is all well and good but this was not something the Athenians followed. The Melians needed to align themselves with another stronger group if they wanted security so that a balance of power could be established and could buffer or deter hostile acts against there nation.
ReplyDeleteIsn't it possible that the Athenians had exactly what you're talking about: a mutually agreed upon code of conduct? They were a democracy!! Couldn't a primary reason for the war be to PRESERVE that code and their way of life? As long as they hold on to power, it would be difficult for anyone to take that away from them. This is why they can't let the Melians remain neutral.
ReplyDelete